What does the new wild bird guidance mean for onshore wind farms in England and Wales?
by Ian Ellis
View post
At SLR we are well versed at supporting our onshore wind clients in navigating consenting issues relating to ornithology. However, there has been no update on the guidance on bird survey requirements in England and Wales since 2015, which coincidentally was the same year that the Conservative government introduced a de facto ban on new developments.
New guidance [1] published this month by Natural England and Natural Resources Wales (NRW) is therefore very much welcomed and will allow developers much needed certainty as to the requirements and timescales involved to collect adequate baseline data. Most importantly, the guidance clarifies when the well-established guidance for Scotland [2] published by NatureScot (mostly recently updated in 2025) applies also to England and Wales… and when it does not.
The updated guidance is particularly relevant to those onshore wind developers currently progressing projects for which ornithology surveys have started or indeed reached completion. How Natural England and NRW intend to advise the application of the updated guidance in those circumstances remains unclear. Pending clarification of some of the key details below, SLR would hope however that surveys that are already in progress which have been designed to meet NatureScot guidance should be treated as being acceptable. This however remains to be seen.
SLR’s initial review of the guidance has highlighted the following key points:
This is required for up to 10km around the site boundary before carrying out field surveys. The 10km suggested here is however less than some foraging distances of certain species, notably geese and gulls, which have been applied by NatureScot. The requirements for the desk study are extensive and there is potential for current work needing to be revisited, with additional costs incurred, to meet the new guidance. The requirement for the desk study to be undertaken before the surveys commence may also create issues for developers whose sites are often confidential at such an early stage.
Methods for standard flight activity (Vantage Point) surveys and subsequent Collision Risk Modelling (CRM) now clearly defer to NatureScot guidance. This provides clarity on matters such as viewsheds and survey effort on which previous advice from Natural England suggested some inconsistency with NatureScot. Taking NatureScot’s guidance as the basis of survey design from now, the aim will be to cover the flight activity survey area such that no point is great than 2km from a Vantage Point.
Additional to the flight activity and species/group specific surveys recommended by NatureScot, the updated Natural England and NRW guidance requires full breeding and non-breeding surveys following the Bird Survey Guidelines [3]. This is a key deviation and has the potential to lead to significant extra data collection for certain sites. SLR routinely applies these methods to our portfolio of projects in lowland England and Wales so this will not be a huge surprise to our clients. The additional requirements will however require focus for upland sites where typically, deployed methods have followed NatureScot guidance.
It is stated by Natural England and NRW that they “do not generally consider survey effort of less than 2 years to be sufficient to inform impact assessment”. This clarity is welcomed, although we consider that for lower risk or repowering sites, justification for 12-18 months’ data collection is often compelling. It is gratifying that Natural England and NRW suggest some flexibility late in the guidance note, in particular in regard to the potential for re-purposing data collected previously on a site or at an adjacent site. This brings into focus however, the importance of Natural England and NRW being able to engage through their Discretionary Advice Service (DAS) process for all relevant projects.
Under the new guidance, survey areas should extend to 600m from the footprint of the proposed development, and 800m where Curlew Numenius arquata is likely to be present. The individual focus on Curlew is notable here and represents another clear deviation from NatureScot guidance who advise a minimum 500m buffer.This discrepancy may be a source of concern for those projects that have surveys underway or recently completed.Natural England and NRW further detail that due to species-specific requirements the total survey area could extend to 6km from the site boundary. NatureScot apply 6km to Golden Eagle Aquila chrysaetos and White-tailed Eagles Haliaeetus albicilla only (due to the size of their breeding territories) which have limited relevance to England and Wales at present. The several White-tailed Eagle reintroduction schemes given approval across England and potentially in Wales, will however bring this into closer focus in future years.
Natural England and NRW refer to NatureScot guidance on assessing cumulative impacts [4]. Application to England and Wales will undoubtedly require detailed consideration at the assessment stage. One example is the potential for a regional scale assessment which is done through Natural Heritage Zones (NHZs) in Scotland; how regional scales will be defined in England and Wales and how reference populations of birds will be defined are not clear from the new guidance.
Our Ornithology team would be pleased to discuss the implications of the updated guidance with clients and intend to engage with Natural England and NRW on the issues raised in this piece in the near future.